Pool Equipment
Pentair vs Jandy vs Hayward. After twenty years of warranty calls.
Every pool builder in Arizona installs one of these three brands. Most pick one because of a rebate program, not because it's the best fit for your pool. Here's what we actually install, what we replace most often under warranty, and which 'equipment package' is really a kickback in disguise.
Pentair
We install- Best at
- IntelliFlo3 VSF pumps, MasterTemp heaters, IntelliCenter automation, IntelliBrite color LEDs, and the AA in-floor cleaning system. Best-in-class energy efficiency on the variable-speed pumps.
- Weak at
- Higher up-front cost. IntelliCenter has a real learning curve for homeowners who just want an on/off button.
- Warranty
- 60 months on most IntelliFlo pumps when registered through a Pentair Platinum dealer (AE qualifies). 24 months on MasterTemp heaters. Salt cell warranty depends on registered cell hours, not the install date.
- AE notes
- Default choice for our premium builds. Parts availability in Arizona is the best of the three. Service techs at every distributor know it cold.
Jandy (Zodiac/Fluidra)
Case-by-case- Best at
- JXi heaters are quiet and compact. AquaLink RS automation is rock-solid once configured. ePump variable-speed is competitive on price.
- Weak at
- We see more PCB board failures on AquaLink panels in the 5–8 year window than on Pentair IntelliCenter. Color LED options are thinner.
- Warranty
- 24-month parts on most equipment. JXi heaters get an extra 12 months on the heat exchanger when installed by a ProEdge Platinum dealer.
- AE notes
- Great middle-tier choice. We spec Jandy when a homeowner already has Jandy plumbing or when budget rules out IntelliCenter.
Hayward
Case-by-case- Best at
- TriStar VS pumps are fairly priced and easy to service. OmniLogic automation is the most homeowner-friendly app of the three.
- Weak at
- Universal H-Series heater bonnet corrosion in coastal-like conditions (yes, even in Arizona — chlorinated indoor enclosures qualify). AquaRite salt cells underperform Pentair IC40s on cell life in our experience.
- Warranty
- 36 months on TriStar VS, 24 months on most heaters, prorated on salt cells.
- AE notes
- We install Hayward when a homeowner explicitly requests it or when they want OmniLogic specifically. Solid brand, but not our default.
Spec Compare
Head-to-head, by the numbers.
| Capability | Pentair | Jandy | Hayward |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premium variable-speed pump | IntelliFlo3 VSF | ePump VS | TriStar VS Omni |
| Variable-speed Energy Star rated | |||
| Most-installed flagship heater (400k BTU) | MasterTemp 400 | JXi 400 | Universal H400 |
| Heat exchanger warranty (registered) | 24 mo | 36 mo (Platinum) | 24 mo |
| Flagship automation platform | IntelliCenter | AquaLink RS / iAquaLink | OmniLogic / OmniHub |
| App quality (2026, AE field opinion) | |||
| Color-changing LED ecosystem | |||
| Salt cell — typical service life in AZ water | 5–7 yr | 4–6 yr | 3–5 yr |
| In-floor cleaning system option (AA) | |||
| Parts availability across AZ distributors |
The Honest Pros & Cons
Pentair
Pros
- Best variable-speed pump efficiency we've measured
- Longest realistic salt cell life in hard AZ water
- Service network in every AZ distributor
- AA in-floor cleaning is the only true competitor to Paramount
Cons
- Highest equipment-pad cost of the three
- IntelliCenter setup is complex without an installer who knows it
- App is functional but feels two years behind Hayward
Jandy
Pros
- JXi heaters run quieter than MasterTemp or Universal
- iAquaLink app is genuinely good
- Strong middle-tier pricing
Cons
- AquaLink board failures we've seen more than on IntelliCenter
- Salt cell life trails Pentair noticeably
- LED options are limited if a homeowner wants color-show effects
Hayward
Pros
- OmniLogic app is the most user-friendly
- TriStar VS is competitively priced
- Easy to service — parts are interchangeable across model years
Cons
- AquaRite salt cell life is the shortest of the three in AZ
- We've replaced more Universal H-Series bonnets than the other two combined
- Mid-tier feel on the equipment pad — not premium aesthetics
The Bottom Line
For a premium AZ pool we default to Pentair on the pump, heater, salt, and in-floor cleaning, with IntelliCenter automation. For a mid-tier build we spec Jandy. We install Hayward when the homeowner asks for it or when OmniLogic is the priority — it's not a bad brand, it's just not our default.
Brand is only half the equation
Check the contractor and the written scope.
Verify the contractor’s Arizona ROC license, classification and current status. Arizona’s casual or minor-work exemption generally applies only to a project totaling less than $1,000 and has additional conditions. It does not apply when a local building permit is required or the work is part of a larger operation. Review the full exemption before relying on it, and ask for current liability and workers’ compensation insurance information applicable to the work. Verify any contractor, including AE, before signing.
FAQ
Common questions.
Pentair is our default for new builds — parts availability, dealer network in the Valley, and automation ecosystem (IntelliCenter) are the deepest. Jandy is a strong second, especially on iAquaLink automation. Hayward works where the existing system is Hayward and swapping the whole platform doesn't pencil.
8–12 years for a Pentair IntelliFlo or Jandy VS FloPro under normal residential duty and clean bonding. Direct sun exposure and poor bonding shorten that. We shade equipment pads where possible and verify bonding on every install and swap.
For automation, yes — Pentair IntelliCenter talks best to Pentair equipment, iAquaLink to Jandy. Mixing brands works mechanically but limits what the app can control and creates support ambiguity when something fails. We spec one platform per pad.
In Arizona utility rates, a variable-speed pump saves $400–$900/year over a single-speed on a typical residential pool. Payback is usually 2–3 years. Single-speed pumps are also increasingly restricted under APS/SRP efficiency incentives — variable-speed qualifies for rebates that offset the equipment premium.
Related Reading
Keep researching
More honest answers, not sales pitches
Bidding 101
How to read a bid
The line items, PSI, brands, and draw schedule that separate a real bid from a sales pitch.
Read
Fit Guide
Is AE right for you?
Who we're a fit for — and who should hire someone else. Read before you call.
Read
Sales Q&A
Honest answers
Why we're rarely the lowest bid, what happens if you wait, what we won't do.
Read